54% of Consumers Check a Business's Website After a Good Review, BrightLocal Finds

As customers vet local companies before they call, Doodle N Dash explains what a missing site costs.
54% of Consumers Check a Business's Website After a Good Review, BrightLocal Finds
[Source: DesignRush]
Marta Janosi
By , Journalist
Reviewed by Enrique Jose Tabuena, Senior Editor

A visit to a local business's website is the most common step after a positive review, a step taken by 54% of consumers, BrightLocal’s Local Consumer Review Survey 2026 found.

That share was 32% when the survey last asked the question in 2019, a 22-point rise.

The vendor, which sells local search and reputation software, polled 1,002 US adults and published the results in February.

Reviews also move real spending. In fact, 93% of consumers bought after reading them and 27% spent more than $1,000.

That spending depends on what the shopper finds at the next click.

A separate 2025 survey from the same firm reached 778 US small- and medium-business owners and managers. Only 40% said they have a dedicated website.

The first survey polled consumers, and the second polled owners, so the figures don't add up to a loss rate.

Still, they do point to a risk. A positive review can send a buyer to a business that has no dedicated website.

Customers Click Through to Competitors

The BrightLocal consumer survey sorted the steps into research and purchase. After a positive review, 66% of consumers do more research, while 34% are ready to buy or book.

Reading more reviews (37%) follows the website visit.

That means most shoppers treat a review as the start of their research. Ahmad Sohail, founder of the web design agency Doodle N Dash, says word of mouth triggers the same check.

"Someone hears about you from a friend, then looks you up. That check takes a minute, and it’s where the referral either holds or falls apart," he says.

The website is the one part of that minute a business controls. BrightLocal’s own advice is to keep the site current and consistent with its reviews.

Sohail describes what happens when that minute turns up nothing.

"The customer doesn’t stop being interested, they just go somewhere else. A good review gets someone to the point of considering you," he explains.

"Then they search for you, find nothing, and click the next result, which is usually a competitor who does have a site. The business did the hard part, earning the trust, and someone else collects it."

Nothing visibly goes wrong when that happens, Sohail adds, so the owner never sees the shopper who searched and moved on.

Meanwhile, 58% of owners are very confident customers can find them online, BrightLocal's Small Business Marketing Report 2026 found. Another 26% are fairly confident.

Referrals Mask a Thin Web Presence

Nearly half of consumers (49%) trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations, the 2026 survey reported.

For a business that lives on referrals, that puts a friend’s word and a stranger's rating side by side in the same search.

Sohail recalls a therapist whose clients mostly arrived by word of mouth. The therapist came to Doodle N Dash for a new website. He describes the old site this way.

"They had one on Squarespace, but it was basically a small placeholder photo and a contact form, and it didn’t show up when you searched for them," he says.

That mattered because a therapist’s experience and credentials are what people need to see, Sohail says. Word of mouth had kept the owner from seeing how little the page showed.

That changed during web design discovery, the planning stage where the agency asks about the business.

In Sohail's account, people look a therapist up before they walk in, searching for the therapist's specialty and approach.

"The referral got people to the door, and the website was what they saw when they got there. Our job was to make sure it showed who they actually are," he says.

An appointment-based practice depends on its website more than on direct contact.

Case in point, after reading a positive review, 20% of consumers make an appointment and 20% contact the business, per BrightLocal's survey. More than twice as many visit the website.

Social Pages Are Rented Space

Among the platforms small and medium businesses use to market themselves online, Facebook (50%) and Instagram (44%) rank ahead of a dedicated website, the 2025 survey found.

Sohail takes a measured view of that approach.

"A social page is a good start, and I’d never tell someone to drop it. But it's rented space," he says.

A social platform sets the layout and changes its rules, he adds. In his view, people searching for a business want fast answers about what it does and why they can trust it.

"A website gives you one place built for that, and you own it," Sohail explains.

"I usually suggest thinking of social as how people find you and the website as where they decide."

That split fits the review data. Social channels draw 24% of consumers after a positive review, less than half the share that visits the website an owner controls, the 2026 survey found.

And because the website draws the bigger audience after a review, the page an owner controls is the one most shoppers visit before deciding.

Review Work Needs a Site

Collecting reviews is steady work. The first threshold is volume, since 47% of consumers will not use a business with fewer than 20 reviews, according to BrightLocal data.

Recency sets the second threshold, as 74% of consumers care only about reviews written in the last three months. The work does not stop once a business reaches 20.

Answering reviews is also part of the job, and 89% of consumers expect owners to respond.

That effort sends visitors to the business, and Sohail describes what happens when no site is waiting for them.

"For the businesses without a site, that’s a lot of people who were ready to take the next step with nowhere to land," he says.

"Every good review is an introduction, and without a website it doesn’t lead to anything."

An owner who has a site can check it against the reviews in minutes. Read the latest ones, note what they praise, and see whether the homepage's first screen says the same.

👍👎💗🤯
Latest Marketing News
Receive our NewsletterJoin over 70,000 B2B decision-makers growing their brands