Maybelline Reunites Lacey Chabert and Dustin Milligan in Holiday Microdrama

Maybelline New York is asserting its place in holiday culture with the debut of a five-part microdrama series, "Maybe This Christmas."

The brand collaborated with Ryan Reynolds’ Maximum Effort agency to secure Lacey Chabert and Dustin Milligan, who previously starred in the hit holiday film "Hot Frosty."

The microdrama format taps into rising cultural momentum and the enduring appeal of seasonal storytelling.

The number one makeup brand campaign delivers a playful twist on the classic holiday romance genre.

The creative centers on two neighbors whose flirtation across NYC windows quickly unravels into a mystery about illusion and what one chooses to conceal.

This focus shows Maybelline’s strategy to prioritize moments that shape culture and deepen its connection with its community.

The Concealment Twist That Powers the Story

The creative strategy succeeds by using genre subversion to integrate the product naturally into the narrative.

The microdrama is positioned as a fun little wink to the mystery genre, which remains light and whimsical with a surprising ending.

The core plot hinges on the idea of concealment, intentionally linking the mystery to the brand's cult-favorite product: the Instant Eraser Concealer.

Yasmin Dastmalchi, president of Maybelline U.S., said in a statement:

"This holiday season, we're excited to bring a fresh, dynamic storytelling approach to life with 'Maybe This Christmas.'

We're able to elevate a product that's been a true staple for our consumers in a way that feels playful and creatively-driven."

Leaning into the playful nature of the advert allowed the agency to avoid forced product placement, making the integration feel earned.

Chabert and Milligan bring proven chemistry and a built-in fanbase, and the series’ bite-sized episodes make their reunion even more engaging.

Leveraging Fandom and Microdrama

The campaign’s success rests on its choice of talent and distribution format for the five-episode microdrama format, which directly addresses declining attention spans.

By debuting the series across YouTube, TikTok, and the short-form platform ReelShort, Maybelline ensures the cinematic creative is distributed.

Gen Z and younger millennials tend to consume content on social media, and the brand pivoted the idea effectively, turning a traditional ad into a bingeable micro series.

The Maybelline microdrama provides clear lessons on cultural trends and product integration:

• Use External Creator IP: Invest in pre-existing chemistry and fandom (Lacey Chabert/Dustin Milligan) to import immediate narrative trust into the brand’s campaign.
• Build Story Around Function: Create a story (mystery/concealment) that makes the physical product function (concealer) the central plot point, transforming the storytelling.
• Match Format to Platform: Avoid long-form ads on short-form platforms. Divide it into episodic and bingeable content for social channels.

This campaign confirms that modern advertising demands brands to stop interrupting entertainment and start becoming the entertainment itself.

Our Take: Is Short-Form Becoming the New Home for Big Stories?

I think so. What Maybelline and Maximum Effort pulled off here shows how long-form storytelling can thrive inside a short-form world when you give people something worth following.

The microdrama gives audiences real entertainment value, not just messaging, and asks for their attention in a way that feels fair.

We get a mini story, a mystery, and a reunion, all packaged in a format people already love to binge.

What stands out to me is how the episodic approach spreads the brand’s presence across platforms.

Instead of one big ad buy, the narrative unfolds in moments, making the concealer feel like part of the plot.

And in the background, we can see Maximum Effort sharpening its creative identity. Now operating independently from MNTN, the agency is leaning harder into culturally aware storytelling.

Find an elite partner to unleash your brand's next unconventional creative success: see the Top Creative Agencies on DesignRush.